AI tools name businesses based on earned media, not paid ads. PR expert Patrick McCaully shows small business owners how to earn coverage that gets cited.
GROWTH PILLAR: Marketing & Branding
WHO THIS IS FOR: SMB owners / Solopreneurs / Leaders building systems
WHAT THEY’LL GAIN: A plain plan to earn media coverage, avoid newsjacking mistakes, and show up in AI answers.
Most owners think ad spend gets them found by AI. It doesn’t. Until you earn real coverage, AI keeps naming your competitors instead.
Patrick McCaully is the founder of Pointman News Creation and a former TV newsroom assignment editor. He explains why PR now matters for AI search. AI tools build your AI story from earned media, not paid ads, and they back it up with citations. Patrick shares how to earn more coverage, why original surveys beat newsjacking, and how humor makes stories stand out. He also covers wire releases, crisis communication, and a realistic PR budget. He says small challenger brands have the edge. This episode is for small business owners who feel invisible and want PR that drives business growth.
Key topics covered
Guest links
Supporting person: Thank you to Carl Richards of Podcast Solutions Made Simple for the introduction.
— PARTNERS ON THIS EPISODE —
Next Steps
Bernie (00:21)
Question to the audience, are you invisible to AI and don't even know it yet? If your business doesn't show up when AI answers your customers' questions,
You have a visibility problem and it's getting bigger every day. Our guest today knows exactly how to fix that. He's been doing it for over 20 years. Patrick McCaully is the founder of Pointman News Creation, the number one ranked boutique PR agency in the world. Based in Toronto, Patrick spent eight years inside the national TV newsrooms at CTV, Citytv and Global, where he sat on the assignment desk and decided which stories got told and which ones got tossed.
He took the insider knowledge and built a PR agency that does one thing well. It creates media coverage that people actually want to read. His clients range from solar founders to major brands like Samsonite, Scouts Canada
He has run more than 600 PR campaigns and earned over 3,000 media hits for a single client. Patrick has a sharp sense of humor and believes funny pitches win. You can find him at pointmannc.com and on LinkedIn at Pointman PR. Patrick, good to see you again. Good to have
Patrick (01:31)
Thanks
for having are you? I'm wonderful. Happy to talk PR anytime.
Bernie (01:36)
Do have a favorite quote or saying you'd to share?
Patrick (01:38)
our company motto is the best ideas win, which I really believe is the key to everything when it comes to public relations.
Bernie (01:46)
So you're working in TV newsrooms and you know that sounds like it's good corporate job. sounds like certain comforts and you don't have to search for clients. People are looking for you actually trying to share stories. Sure. What shifted gears for you to say Stage Left?
Patrick (02:04)
Well, I think you hit it on the head there. It sounds like a great job, but the reality is as an assignment editor, you're sitting there usually alone in a building. At Global TV, for instance, it was a refurbished steel factory where nobody was there except you and the security guy. And you're listening to 12 different police scanners hoping that there'll be a fire or a shooting or something that you can...
send a camera guy or a helicopter to, and spending hours and hours of your life just waiting for that huge story to happen. So I think even like when I got out 25, 27 years ago, it was just obvious to me that other than like the guy who's the anchor, other than the guy who's like a reporter, other than Sean O'Shea, who I have tremendous respect for and probably has the best career in Canadian.
television history, because he's done the same thing for like 30 years. The consumer reporting does it very well and, you know, really works on his own terms. There aren't a lot of great jobs in journalism and it's only gotten worse. So I think I probably had an epiphanal moment some weekend on the assignment desk, you know, three o'clock in the morning, not seeing the sun. Maybe I can do this better. Maybe I can make more money, see the daylight, have a life.
and really have more influence on the news being in PR than I can actually sitting at the desk and deciding what to send a camera to. And I turned out to be right.
Bernie (03:34)
I guess you would have seen a lot of PR agencies trying to get content pushed through the system.
Patrick (03:39)
yes, every day, several times, you'd get a call from one of the big agencies. I won't name names, but big agencies that you heard of. And there's a lot of like, hey, I know you're probably not interested in this, but my boss really wants me to work this list. So can I just give you my pitch and then I can cross you off? And it's like, they're calling when you're listening to police scanners, you're probably.
sending out a camera guy, you're filling out paperwork, you're looking through press releases, you're ripping wire off of a wire, you know, like back in the old days, actual wire copy off of a machine that goes ding, ding, ding, and you rip the wire off. like, I, you know, respectfully, I don't have time for you to give me a bad pitch. And I got them over and over and over and over and over again. So yeah. And everyone is competing for that.
not a lot of screen time. a standard television story now is like a minute or less. So, you know, it's a, the last meritocracy in the world where you really have to have the best idea to get the story on air.
Bernie (04:47)
So when you launched Pointman in 2001, what were you trying to do different from day one? Obviously you're not going to call the desk and say, it's 3 in the morning. What are you up to? Let's have a chat.
Patrick (04:58)
Yeah, I think my notion was always this, what I call the Trojan horse approach. Like, know, nobody cares that you have a robust service offering. Nobody cares that you have the greatest staff, according to you. Nobody cares that, you you hired some guy. It's, people have a very biased view. And I mean, it makes sense that you would be, you know, excited about things that are happening at your company.
That doesn't mean it's newsworthy. And I think that I've always felt like you really need to lead with something that the media is going to need, be interested in and can use. So what I wanted to do differently was like from other people that I had worked for, from other people that had pitched me when I was a journalist, actually have a story, know, do something that's not based on begging someone to do a story. I mean, I'm proud to say that I don't think I've actually called a journalist for 15 years. It's probably longer than that.
if they didn't call me first, because journalists don't want you to call them. They don't have time for that. They're busier than they ever have been. And like this notion that you're supposed to call journalists to follow up on pitches or you're supposed to take them out to lunch, like it's 1967, that is not the reality of the situation. The reality of the situation is to have actually a good pitch, get them to come to you and make their life easier.
You know, no one does stories because they like you. They do the story because it's the best story.
Bernie (06:28)
I guess that's where the term vanquisher of vanilla PR is coming from then.
Patrick (06:33)
Yeah, it's, well, first of all, alliteration is the key to the universe. People say it's math. I think it's alliteration. And the other part of that is it's kind of a, it's a bit of a way to differentiate myself and get clients coming to me that I'll already understand that I'm doing something different and saying something different. So I think people who work with me have to be able to do something a little bit different.
They have to be able to be bold and go outside of their comfort zone. I'm trying to communicate with that, with the whole vanquishing vanilla PR.
Bernie (07:06)
So if someone says, listen, here's my raw idea. This is what I want to do. How do you take it from, yep, that looks like a box of bolts to, look at that. Sweet, sexy, sleek looking machine. How do you take it from, uh-huh, to, wow.
Patrick (07:21)
Yeah, well, I think that's the magic. And I mean, I am maybe notoriously known for being brutal with clients to my own not benefit. Like I won't just say, you know, hey, what's really interesting about your robust service offering? Well, that sounds great. Thank you for the bag of money. I guess it didn't work out, but I appreciate you giving me a bag of money. I will not do something that I don't think is gonna work.
I think that's unique in the industry as well. So I mean, the idea doesn't have to come from me, sometimes the clients. I mean, like when I say sometimes, I mean like 99.9 % of the time it's me, but every once in a while somebody has a great idea and you just know it when you hear it. How to execute that, how to make it into something that's media friendly, that's the genius of the job.
Yeah, I think it's taking a core idea or something you wanna talk about and then adding something really interesting to it to make it irresistible to the media. So like a quick example, I do work for the Writers Guild of Canada. They represent like 2,500 television and movie writers. And we wanted to do something about AI and how AI cannot write the Canadian experience well. So we wanted to do something funny.
So the idea that we came up with was feeding the lines, the best lines in Canadian television history into AI and saying, improve these, pretty much knowing that it wouldn't, right? Like it wouldn't make them better. So for example, the classic Degrassi Junior High song, everybody wants something, never give up, you take your money and never give up, that old deal. Put that into AI.
And it spit out like everybody wants dollars in order to have more money and lifestyle. Everyone, everybody wants something that is expensive, but they can't get normally. Like it's something, was just, it was awful, right? So it was really a fantastic illustration of the problem in a funny way. And then we actually got Andrew Fung from Kim's Convenience and the neighborhood and that kind of stuff. He is a, is a member.
of the Writers Guild and he was willing to do like an on-camera thing. So we had a really cool, like Andrew Fung reading the list of like the really bad lines. And we kind of put that out with it. And it was, I mean, it was a massive, massive success, award-winning, international award-winning pitch in fact. But that's how you take like a kernel of an idea, but make it build it out into something that's funny and interesting and that the media can use. And it's going to get like a really wide syndication and distribution. mean, I think it was over a hundred.
Media hits for that.
Bernie (10:00)
I was at someone, these two guys were on a, on a podcast. It was posted on Instagram, a short, short little story. And they had three different AI, uh, uh, running a, uh, a show, a talk show. And, the one, which is the, um, ChatGPT started a radio station at 24 seven. And it just, it just, it just got silly. I think Grok was the other one. And it was just like,
It had nonsense words like, know, it just jumbled it up. Claude says, yeah, no, no one needs this 24 seven and we're shutting it down. So it was interesting. Three different paths. Same, same prompt.
Patrick (10:42)
It decided to self terminate, it took its own life because it wasn't valuable enough.
Bernie (10:46)
Yeah, I said, no, no, no one needs to listen to this 24 7. No, stop. Which is funny, right? Yes.
Patrick (10:52)
this.
Bernie (10:53)
Knowing that AI is kind of a tool to be found and you capitalize on it's just not the it's not the poetic master per se. How do you leverage AI then to, you know, make you do A B tests with that where you're doing comparison like hot gold or what?
Patrick (11:13)
Yeah, mean, well, so interestingly, and I've been using this a lot lately, Mailchimp, I tend to send to a large media list, and Mailchimp has an A-B test for email subject lines. So that's a really cool way of like, because I'll come up with like eight, and then, you know, you can test eight different email subject lines and see which one really works, and then just go back to that, you know, like keep, and it automatically does it, like it's really cool, like it'll,
test them with a small sample of like 30 media and then decide out of two of them, which one works the best. And then you can kind of use that one and another, you know, like a round Robin tournament kind of thing. And you end up ultimately getting the best headline that's the most effective, which is great. And there's some practical uses for AI that keep me from doing grunt work, like finding journalists. can like program an agent to find journalists that have made a...
a career move in the last year or in the last two weeks and you've got to scrape LinkedIn to find that information. So that's useful. know, Q and A's, it's pretty good at generating stuff. mean, there's always a lot that you have to change, but at least it gets you like a baseline of things that you can use. I mean, I'm definitely trying to embrace it as opposed to give it to my natural fear of Skynet killing us all.
The Singularity.
Bernie (12:32)
The red eyes that are chasing after me won't stop. Yeah. Thank you.
Patrick (12:36)
Exactly.
Bernie (12:37)
So, but being found, uh, through AI searches, cause that's like, you know, people in the past are, you know, Google me right now. Now it's not Google me anymore. Well, I don't think they're going to go away. It's just, it's just going to up there. They're going to up their game with Gemini, but how do you get AI? Uh, how do get a business and leverage the AI?
AI findability, for lack of better words.
Patrick (13:02)
So this is really interesting. And this is really in the last six or seven months, this is completely seismically shifted PR. So there's all the reasons that PR was important before that third party credibility, getting that endorsement, something that isn't paid so people know the difference between editorial and advertorial. AI, there was a study that came out a couple of months ago by Muck Rack, which is like a distribution platform for PR people.
And it found that 82 % of what AI sites when they're looking for like, you know, the best plumber in Toronto or the best PR agency in Canada or whatever it is, is based on earned media coverage. So it knows the difference between things that are paid and that are not paid. And it's that earned media credibility that really makes a difference, really moves the needle. And you get mentioned over your...
So it's like, it's a crazy advantage that I wish I could say that marketing directors have picked up on. It's, it's a slow process to be screaming from the rooftops of how big a deal this is. think everyone's going to get there, but at the moment there's a cautious interest, not full, you know, deep dive into it, which people should be doing. So for a practical standpoint, getting
earned media coverage often and a lot of it, not like three stories, like 50 stories, 100 stories, 25 stories. And then there's other things you can do too. Like it'll look at your website. So have a news section that has every single bit of coverage that you've gotten that mentions you in it. It'll look at that, read it really quickly and evaluate your worthiness, you know, based on those hits. Wikipedia pages.
are important, rankings are important. It looks at stuff like that, because it really knows the difference between things that are paid and things that have to be independently earned, right? So Clutch, for instance, if you're a marketing person is an amazing platform and they rank everything, business people, coaches, PR people, we're the number one boutique agency in the world on Clutch. And yes, thank you.
You you need to look at stuff like that. The one, let me give you this one pitch that, or one free thing that is currently true that might not be true tomorrow is you can write a press release, Pointman News Creation says they're amazing according to them and send that out over an aggregator service, like a wire service, like EIN Presswire Network is pretty cost effective, it's like $200.
$300 US and you get to distribute to Canada and the US, you send that out over that wire and it'll get picked up on aggregator sites. like Globe and Mail, you're not gonna get in the Globe and Mail like editorially, but the Globe and Mail has a section that's just for press releases that are on this wire. So, you know, it'll get picked up sorta by the Globe and Mail. And what that does is no journalist is ever gonna care about that, but.
it will move the needle not as much as earned media, but it will move the needle on AI citations. And that's currently a loophole, because you are paying for it, and it is you talking about you as opposed to a third party. I'm sure that that's going to be like next week off the table. So do that now. I've done it twice for awards that we've won. That's actionable data right there.
Bernie (16:33)
incredible. So does it matter whether you're doing a sound bite, a written content or visual imagery or a film or a TikTok or Facebook or LinkedIn? do you kind of like, if you have a message to get out there, I mean, you're going to target the audience that needs to hear it. I get that part. Does it also capture all that and then the visuals?
Patrick (16:56)
I mean, that's an interesting question because if you have, you know, broadcast coverage, a lot of the stuff I do, cause it's very kind of zeitgeist and new and talk of the day, we'll get on radio, it'll get on television. How does that end up being something that AI could cite if it only has aired on a broadcast network or on radio? The truth is a lot of stuff is shared now.
and syndicated throughout. So Global TV has a whole bunch of radio stations, TV stations, and they have, you know, GlobalNews.ca. So likely if it's a big story, it's gonna end up on the website. And that's where, you know, you point to with your social media and everything else and that you would get the citation from. If it doesn't...
happen and it just kind of airs on the radio station or the television station. I've started doing, just this week actually, I learned how to do this. I learned something new, supercut videos on Descript. So I actually asked Claude, what's the best and easiest platform to edit supercut videos of earned media coverage? And it said, Descript.
So it's, it's, I wouldn't say it's the easy, I figured it out in a week. but you can basically take all of those radio segments and you can take your TV segments and cut them together into a really cool video with music under it and titles and all of that. And then, yeah, you would put that on your website. would spell out exactly what it is. Maybe put a transcript of everything that's on there. Again, everything that you do.
has to be thinking about AI citations. So, and on your own website, like I have a fair number of awards, which as you can see, I never talk about, but I list those the way that Claude says to list them so that AI people can pick up on that and get those citations. So, I guess it begins with asking actual AI programs.
how can I be more visible to you? What are the 10 things I can do differently on my website? How can I leverage my PR? And it really is changing every day. Like I had a conversation with a colleague about, you the specialization of being like an AI PR person. That's kind of BS right now, because it's so new. Nobody knows and it's changing every day. So there's no gold standard yet. It's Wild West, but it's a great opportunity to get out on the bottom.
Bernie (19:23)
One of things I found in researching out, putting out content and make it more visible is when I put the podcast out, there's a part where I can the, park the transcript in there. So when it goes out and apparently the bots love that, I don't know if anybody's going to go through the transcript. Well, at minute two, Bernie says, and guests at minute three said that, you know, so it's just, but that's kind of the food for the fodder. And even, even the platform where I'm doing the blog, apparently that also
feeds into the grand schema of things. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Patrick (19:56)
I mean, you know, sorry, another
Bernie (19:57)
Yeah, go ahead. No,
Patrick (19:59)
really interesting thing is that like different different AIs look at media differently. So, you know, ChatGPT might be just kind of looking at the major networks and the bigger publications, but apparently Claude really likes trade publications and smaller community publications for expertise. So they're all, it's not just like one, you know,
one size fits all strategy. It's really, you know, all of these different things that are changing every day that you have to keep up on and understand and adapt to.
Bernie (20:34)
When you're doing PR, do you also encourage your clients to get involved with community back giving back to community with it? If I mean, if they're small and local, your typical one is, you have a local soccer team, local football team or local baseball team, you know, and their their kids ages from five to maybe 10. And you buy them jerseys. Is that another method of leveraging a PR where you're doing that? Or is that does that?
Patrick (21:00)
I mean, it's marketing, it's not PR. There'd only be like a hyper local opportunity for media to get excited about that. But I have done things. I worked with the Commonwealth Mutual Insurance Company for years and we did a get a free coffee day. And it was actually really interesting because we didn't say who did it, who was behind it. It was just like, guess what? Everyone in like Eastern Ontario
the Commonwealth is going to pay for free coffee for you tomorrow or sorry, an anonymous donor is going to pay for a free coffee for you tomorrow. And I mean, that's absolutely, you know, community service and doing things locally and on a micro scale, but it was a big enough pitch that it ended up getting a lot of coverage across Ontario because it was a whole thing. People surprisingly, one lady, the one lady that of course was there when the broadcast guys showed up.
was like, I can pay for my own coffee. So it's amazing to me sometimes the objections that people have, but by and large, very positive, lots of media coverage, good feeling, you know, there's, there's ways to make it into a bigger story, but like the, hyper local thing, you know, I think that's very hit or miss. and it can be seen as sort of self-serving to a certain extent. So you have to kind of come up with a bigger idea or something that's again,
sort of more newsworthy than the uniform thing, which I think is great for marketing and like put it on your social media and, you know, let people know about it, but it's not, it's not really a move.
Bernie (22:28)
So is it more like the naming rights for a stadium to become APR move? Big
Patrick (22:33)
Sure, yeah.
Bernie (22:34)
Jersey, the super big Jersey.
Patrick (22:37)
You know, think big. mean, one of my favorite, so I'm not a fan of this organization. I don't like what they do at all, but Ashley Madison, infamously, are ridiculously good at PR. They do, I mean, one of the things they did every year and basically did the same thing every year and still outsmarted like CBS was they would pay the fee to have a Super Bowl ad.
And then they would film a Super Bowl ad, probably at minimal cost, knowing 100 % that the CBS morality clause would never allow them to actually have to pay, I don't know, $3 million for a Super Bowl ad. And then when they were told that they couldn't air the Super Bowl ad, they would do a whole like, it's censorship. like, you know, the government is putting its foot in our bedrooms. And I mean,
And like once, wow, like that still is a great, but like, think they did it like five or six times where, you know, they were, they were going to name a penguin habitat or something.
Bernie (23:44)
A penguin habitat.
Patrick (23:45)
The Ashley Madison penguin habitat.
Bernie (23:48)
Were they fighting mates for the penguin or what?
Patrick (23:49)
I mean, I don't know.
Bernie (23:51)
That might be the progression.
Patrick (23:52)
I mean, love is love, whatever. But I mean, you have to admire the audacity of an idea like that. So, yeah. I mean, do I think you got to go big? Absolutely. Like, so right now the world's melting. It's, you know, you could have a fantastic pitch and the Strait of Hormuz could blow up or, you know, Trump could say anything or who knows. So you really can't pull punches and you better go with your best pitch.
you better feel really confident about it. Cause it's very easy to get lost in the lights on so much happening. And bear in mind, you still have like thousands of PR people pitching the same outlets to get the same amount of coverage. you know, the notion of doing something small or doing something that isn't really interesting or that's self-serving or that you're pulling punches on, like it's don't do that. Just go for it. Cause you have to.
Bernie (24:44)
How do you handle it? You've lined everything up. The stars are all aligned. You got this great pitch. You about to fire something out the door and then someone in the universe at large, Strait of Hormuz, for example, does something. They flip a switch independent of you and you're independent of them. But all of a sudden, and we're just kind of now just got ground out. How do you counter that? Or you just pull back and then reload at a quieter time?
Patrick (25:10)
I mean, and again, I would venture to say that I do things differently than most people, but I'm a big plan B guy. when I do, I would say the majority of the pitches that I do, I don't really believe in events because it's too much pressure on one day and limited resources to show up and do it. yeah, nothing bad can happen. know, like try doing a, trying to do an event in Toronto when Doug Ford was the mayor, you know, like that is risky.
So I'm a big fan of doing like a poll. So ask a thousand Canadians in an online poll, whatever the question is. And then you can like one, you can ask 25 questions. You can have like really three completely different directions to go in based on those questions that you're asking or even more sometimes. You can compare.
national data to provincial data to age to, you know, gender, whatever, uh, in order to make different stories. And you just, your odds of success are much, much better because you'll have at least two weeks to pitch something and, you know, different directions. So this actually happened to me recently where, um, I had a pitch. was, there was a small business, a digital marketing company, um, and we decided to target small businesses. Ask.
What are pain points of small businesses? And I mean, a lot of different people do the insurance companies do this and the Canadian Federation of Independent Business does this and RBC does this, you know, so you can never know what everyone else is coming out with. We did a thing on fake-triotics, which unfortunately I didn't invent that word, but I really love it. It's the notion of you say your elbows up and you're supporting Canadian and then you go to Walmart to save money.
Who can blame you really, but it's the fake-triotic part of it that's bad. So we did a survey to like 600 small business people and asked them what they thought about that and who was the most patriotic province and like, did they think it was happening? And they think that small businesses themselves are fake-triotic and we're doing pretty well with it. It got a nice initial blast. And then we had a whole bunch of other questions. You know, do you think that you're going to be able to hold on
until retirement with your small business or you'll go under, how long could you live without money? Like a week, a month, a year, you know, that kind of thing. And unfortunately for us, and this was like maybe a month ago, two months ago, CFIB came out with a really big survey and was getting a ton of media coverage. So we did okay. think altogether we were at about 68 media hits, which is well above normal, but you know, wasn't...
Super happy with how that went just because there was so much competition. RBC came out with something. was like a rate comparison site put out something. So there was just like this glut of completely unforeseen small business surveys out there. So what do you do? Well, I think most people would say, hey, we got you 68 media hits. That's great. You can't know what's out there and we did our best.
going to do another, a last pitch. I did, I probably do about four different pitches between the press release initially, and then, you know, different email subject lines and then breaking out information. So I've done maybe four or five of those already. And then there were some major markets where I hadn't done that in. So I'm going to be pushing that out at the end of the month. Hopefully there's enough time has gone by where they don't feel like there's been a lot of small business news, but it's sometimes it's that sometimes it's.
understanding that there's just too much news happening and you can't do anything about it. So come back to it later, which I think you can do.
Bernie (28:54)
You ever piggyback on someone else's like, not so much to, I mean, kudos to what they're putting out and you recognize that, you know, the source, but do you ever leverage someone else's output going, yeah, here, here's a big research study. Now, this small niche market here, this, you know, does this matter to you? And then you kind of focus on that.
Patrick (29:13)
So the problem there is, I mean, I personally, so they call it news jacking.
Bernie (29:17)
Okay, sorry. That's so good.
Patrick (29:19)
Yeah,
I know it sounds, it sounds aggressive somehow, doesn't it? And it is, it is. So news jacking, I feel like it's kind of ambulance chasing. So I don't like leveraging off of anyone else's work. And also everyone in the world who is in your category is going to be trying to do that. So why would you do what everybody else is doing? The person that's going to get
The coverage is going to be the first person that contacted them that had a spokesperson lined up and, you know, got lucky. Right. I, I don't like leveraging off of other people's stuff. like to have original, whether it's proprietary data, or we did a survey or something like that, just so we're definitely saying something different and we have our own sources. I've had, recently the CBC, which is an enigma and it's.
in its own right, didn't like the statistical veracity of a survey that I'd put together. They're very, the two outlets that really care about that are CBC and the Globe. And they have a whole department of people that won't tell you what the standards are, but will just tell you that you're not at the standard. And they actually took the topic of a press release that I sent out.
and got someone else to do basically the same questions and then interviewed that person. yeah. So, I mean, that's the danger with newsjacking is that you might give them an idea and they interview your competitor because it's not your information is the point.
Bernie (30:46)
Yeah.
Patrick (30:48)
They don't owe you anything. That's the biggest misconception.
that founders and CMOs have is that somehow the media owes them a story because they exist or they did something that they think is interesting. That's not true. The media doesn't work for you. It's about you giving them something.
Bernie (31:07)
So in the PR land, almost sounds like there's several buckets. One is I'm doing something new. I'm launching a new whatever it is. One is an awareness campaign. I can think of a different awareness like don't text and drive, don't drink and drive, those type of campaigns. And then there's a third leg where it's like, and there might be more.
The third leg is whoops, something went sideways and we're in the news, but not not how we intended to, when an airplane, when an airplane, let's say a Pearson decides not to stop at the end of the runway, but further. Yeah.
Patrick (31:42)
Yeah, I there's, always want to be, I think the advantage of news creation where you're using like a survey or your proprietary data is that you are releasing it on your own schedule and you don't have to compete with everything else that's going on in the world. And hopefully it's an original enough idea that you're not competing with someone who's doing something similar, although you can never really know that. yeah, and I mean, crisis communications is a whole different thing. A lot of the time,
the smart money is on not saying anything unless you have to, or, doing like a, like a holding statement. it's very hard to convince people not to do interviews, but, and he, and he never, the problem is you never know what you gained by not doing an interview, but you just, cause you don't really see, there's a lot of afterwards, maybe we should have talked about that, but I never, I, I never.
counsel people to talk about something unless someone got hurt, unless there's a death, unless it's not gonna go away. Like I used this example a while ago, like that whole deal with the people at the Coldplay concert, that was an epic fail in every single way, right? So this thing happens, it's kind of funny, there's celebrities involved.
Obviously that's going to be news for a couple of days. You know? So, so what do they do? They immediately fire the person that bought the tickets. Because it's, you know, it's their fault, clearly not the people that were having an affair publicly at a Coldplay concert. And then they paid, I don't know how many million dollars to get Gwyneth Paltrow, know, Chris, Chris Martin, the lead singer of Coldplay's X to do a whole thing about, about the company and
You know, nod, nod, wink, wink. We really care about our employees and, you know, and it's just like, so you spent a lot of money. You, you, you, you're supposed to suck the oxygen out of stories that you don't want. don't like continue them. And, and, and they, you know, they, they, did the whole ad campaign. Like they could have just waited to see what happened. I think it all went down, like on a Thursday or something. I would have at least waited the weekend to see how that played out. And if something horrible happened, you know, Trump.
God knows in this news cycle, something can happen and just take 100 % of the attention off of you. Yet they did this whole misguided, you know, humor campaign showing how little they care about their employees and that they have a sense of humor, I guess. So just very, very badly handled communications.
Bernie (34:13)
Awkward.
Patrick (34:14)
Yeah.
Bernie (34:14)
Awkward. Very awkward. So from a small business side, do you think the small business is in a better advantage than a big brand? mean, resource is a big brand. They can go, hi, here's gobs of money. Make something happen, right? Keep applying it till something sticks. But does a small business have a better sense of, that's working?
because it makes sense that the loops are shorter. In other words, you're not going through five different departments.
Patrick (34:41)
Yeah. And I, I really, I would a hundred percent of the time rather work with like the number two or the number three or the number five in the category, because if you're the number one, you legitimately have things to lose by doing, you know, ballsy, bold PR campaigns. and you have to worry about offending people and you have to worry about a lot more because you're an established brand. If you're the challenger brand, you're supposed to challenge, you know, you have this.
nothing to lose in order to get out there and get people to know who you are and, doing something a little different, you know, to, to get that, bad attention and, yeah, less, less, hoops to jump through less, you know, a lot of times, the American, companies that have a Canadian office will decide that they know better.
what works in this country. That's not always true. There's a bit of a weird imbalance there. So I think, if you're not the number one, if you're a small business, it's nothing but positive to do something bold and try to get media coverage and be seen as the upstart.
Bernie (35:52)
What type of budget should a small company kind of map out for, for a good PR campaign?
Patrick (35:58)
Yeah, I mean, again, it depends who you're working with, but I would say, you know, between fees and maybe a survey and sending some out over Canada Newswire, which is an expensive but effective tactic, you probably need somewhere between 10 and 15K Canadian to do a really effective PR campaign. Some people will charge you more. Some people will insist on a retainer.
as opposed to a project, but that's the kind of budget that you need to really do something impactful.
Bernie (36:28)
Have you ever had someone come up and say, listen, I've got a business, I've got a story. I don't know, it might be, you know, as dull as watching paint dry. Is that something you can turn this into the most marvelous story ever and then you can watch the paint actually bubbling into fresh air or what?
Patrick (36:46)
Well, so anecdotally, I had a guy who called up and he said, look, I've been a financial planner for 30 years and I have a self-published book about my adventures being a financial analyst. And this is definitely the best time for me to try to get PR. And I was like, look, man, that's great that you have a book that you self-published. And I mean, that's a great marketing tool and it's a great like door opener or anything, but the media doesn't care.
No one cares that you have a self-published book. So if you want to get media covers, let's do something completely different. So we ended up doing fake investment terms, which is just funny. premise is Canadians are too polite. So we don't really know what we're invested in. We don't ask enough questions. So we did a survey, 2,000 Canadians. And we asked like, do you have DSP 2016 and forward yield disbursement funds and
uh, white chip stocks and, just made stuff up. It sounded real, but wasn't. like 40 % said, Oh yeah, I got DSP 2016 doing really, doing really well for me. You know, thus illustrating the point. And, uh, we got a ton of media coverage with that. Um, we got, uh, the front page of the Globe and Mail Business section who would probably argue that that wasn't a statistically.
acceptable poll, but it was funny and interesting and, you know, the right time, right place. and he even got a regular gig on 680 News commenting on markets because they're like, this guy's different. He has an interesting voice. He's saying things that other people don't say. So, I am not afraid to tell someone something's a bad idea. I frequently do.
Bernie (38:29)
So you just mentioned something was interesting. The guy's got an interesting voice. So if you have, is there a type of persona that goes, that's a ticket. Come here. Here's a microphone on camera. Stand here, smile and you know, go for it.
Patrick (38:42)
Yeah, well, mean, literally and figuratively in this case. so this guy, he kind of had an interesting voice. It was kind of a, you know, sounded different just, you know, initially. but then, I mean, and also, I mean, in a more existential sense, he's saying things that other people don't say, cause you know, financial analysts are pretty conservative and they don't, there aren't a lot of colorful, there's a few, Wackerly is a color, colorful character.
You know, Mr. Wonderful is a colorful character, but I mean, very few really legitimately interesting people in the business. you know, saying something different, adding some humor, very, very underused. Like it always amazes me how little humor PR people use in their pitches. Because they think, God, the media is so much smarter and they're so much more prepared and they're to see through this and they don't have a sense of humor. It's like, no, they're just like you and me.
They want to make the donut and go home. That's what's happening. So make it easier for them to do that, but also amuse them. Send them something that's legitimately interesting. Cause there's a board assignment editor, you know,
Bernie (39:53)
in the morning.
Patrick (39:54)
three in the morning. I have a picture over my shoulder of me at Global TV as a very sleepy looking assignment editor during the day. I just, every once in a while I look at it I think, yeah, remember that guy.
You know, remember how awful his life is and try to make the pitch interesting for him. Cause someone asked him.
Bernie (40:14)
Well, it's also know your audience, right? And what matters to them?
Patrick (40:18)
Yeah.
Bernie (40:18)
So we just talked about a lot of different things, AI, we talked about the journalism and staying, is it newsworthy for them? Are you going to turn their head? In five years from now, where do you think this is all going to look like? Do you think that you're going to have 3D avatars kind of going through? hear about AI now, and I noticed it on Instagram. You can have it where the model is going.
Do think I'm real or fake? Right? I'm fake. says, Holy Lifton. it's like, yeah, I look too polished to be real. But it's like, cause you couldn't see flaws. now, you know, do you think we're heading that way or what?
Patrick (40:54)
So, I mean, the good future stuff is Gartner says that by 2027 companies are going to have to double their marketing budget for PR because of this AI reality that you need to come up in the AI search because no one's going to be doing Google. And Google's like down to 25 % of searches or something like that. Like, cause it's a lot easier just to ask Claude to do a big comparison of like all the marketing agencies in Canada and who you should hire and you know.
And we're lazy. So let's be honest. That's going to continue. In terms of what's media going to be like in five years, in 10 years? I mean, think there's always going to be a place. I think it actually becomes more important in this, I mean, post-truth world that we're in, like where it doesn't actually matter if something is true or not. just, yeah,
Bernie (41:44)
I like that term.
Patrick (41:46)
it disturbs me deeply.
And I'm mostly talking about the US here, but, you know, it's like, if you say it long enough and loud enough and with conviction, it doesn't matter where it's true or not. You can say, it was a joke. I thought it was, know, like, no, I never threatened the Pope or whatever. You you can just, you can make things up apparently. And I think we're headed for an inevitable backlash on that.
where things are so constantly false or manipulated that there's going to be a return to some kind of reasonable requirement to be honest and truthful and have consequences if they aren't, right? So influencers, not so much. It's Wild West. You can kind of say whatever you want. You can be completely wrong.
You don't have to back anything up and there's really no consequences. Television people, journalists, there is still probably not enough, but there is still a basic requirement for television stations, radio stations, print to accurately print things, to report things, to be truthful, to not have bias. And we try to make that happen, but
at least there's, you know, a legal requirement or, you know, in the case of Fox News with the talking about the, the boxes that were allegedly tampered with for the election, you end up paying like $500 million. There's, there's financial consequences. So I think that we're, we're due for like a Renaissance of truth, really, you know, where, where that's gonna, that's gonna matter. And, and, and all of those traditional.
earned media outlets become even more important in that reality. The other thing is that because AI is citing earned media and not paid media, and it knows the difference, I think that interestingly, AI companies might have to save journalism.
So what I mean by that is that earned media has to exist in order for AI companies to have citations. So the more that journalism shrinks and there's less and less journalists, that's not good for AI, which is incredibly wealthy and being invested in and doubling in intelligence every day or whatever it is. So I think that there's going to be an inevitable funding of journalism from
tech and AI companies that's going to have to happen because the citations are everything.
Bernie (44:20)
So at end of the day, who is someone you'd partner with or work with, or who's your best fit for a client?
Patrick (44:28)
I I always joke someone who has money and will take my advice, but I'm only half kidding. I don't really negotiate on price. I cost what I cost and it's a reasonable amount for, you know, over 25 years of experience and thousands of media hits and, know, but I need people that are willing to do something different, that are willing to maybe
go a little bit outside their comfort zone that understand the media doesn't owe them anything and they really need to come to the media with something interesting. I've met so many founders and companies that are like, well, the media loves us and we're incredible and we have the best people. And it's like, that's great. I'm sure that's true, but that is not news. It's not, the media doesn't exist.
to give you free publicity, because you think you deserve it, you need to come to them with a truly interesting story in order to get the coverage. It's a meritocracy. And hire someone that has ideas. Another big deficit is that I think a lot of PR people kind of tell you what you want to hear and say, that's very interesting. like, yeah, let's do a press release about that and see what happens. And then, you know.
maybe you get three hits, seven hits. Congratulations, that's great. Maybe you get no hits, because it wasn't newsworthy at all, but like, it's about the ideas.
Bernie (45:56)
What's the most fun pitch you've done? Because I understand you've done beef jerky bouquets, poultry plant whistleblowers, gas giveaways. I'm assuming gasoline for cars. I'll pull
Patrick (46:06)
Yes. Yeah.
Bernie (46:08)
my finger once.
Patrick (46:09)
I mean, there's, some advocacy stuff that I've been able to do. like the CPAWS, which is a conservation organization, we got to do a report card of different provinces and how they were doing on, um, you know, fjords and water and conservation efforts. And we structured it like a, like a kid's report card, which was really funny, you know, so it's kind of like needs improvement on this and like,
needs to stay after class on indigenous rights and that sort of thing. So I loved the pitch itself, but I love the advocacy of that, doing something really positive. It's nice when you can use your evil powers for good, right? I've done a few anti-Trump campaigns where I probably can't go to the US for another four years. I regret nothing.
Someone in 2016 had to be against Trump and we did a whole dump Donald A like E H. So we were selling hats and t-shirts to write a check to Donald Trump to drop out of the election, which he did not, but somebody in Canada was saying that he should, right? So probably the funnest one ever, the craziest one ever was yeah, the for FlightNetwork.com.
we did this, this gas giveaway. we gave away like 10,000 liters of gas for 10 cents a liter. And I mean, there's nothing like gas. It's everyone fundamentally, everyone wants to stick it to the man on gas. we had cars were idling overnight, burning more gas than they were going to get lined up for hours and hours and hours. Just, just to
you know, have the bragging rights of saying I got 10 cent a liter gas. And interestingly, 10 cent a liter gas is far more compelling than free gas for some reason. I don't know why, but for some reason it is. And it wasn't like a crazy expensive execution because it was like the difference between 10 cents and whatever gas was going for a liter at the time. You know, and this was a while ago, know, 10, 15 years ago, but
I think gas was a lot less, but people were still pissed off about it. And I mean, that was like a three hour period. We had like news helicopters, like we're circling. was satellite trucks. there was like tons of journalists. There was, you know, we, we had, off duty cops just in case things got crazy, which they didn't, but there was one, there was one guy that like surged in line and you know, that
one of the outlets got that on camera and made it into a whole, you know, whatever. But it was that particular pitch was, I was particularly proud of and it was, was pretty, it was pretty exciting. It was like lightning in a bottle. I think we got 350 media hits for that three hour period, which is just crazy and unheard of. And then some of the stuff I've done for Scouts Helpline, which was just the idea was like,
kind of loosely based on the Butterball holiday line, like how to prepare a Butterball turkey. You call in and they tell you. So this is like if you're inept and you can't actually camp like me, you call, know, if you lost your paddle, press nine. If you've seen a bear, press two, you know. So and then we had like pre-recorded messages of like what you would do. You know, if it's brown, lay down. If it's black, fight back. Although I think you're probably mostly pooched either
situation. But yeah, that was crazy. That was like 500 media hits per campaign. Everyone wanted to talk about it. Perfect thing for summer. know, so I mean, and I would say the majority of the stuff that has really worked well, that I'm really proud of is humor based. And that's a secret weapon that people just don't use in public relations. For some reason, I don't understand. I don't know.
Bernie (50:08)
So Patrick, I want to say thank you so much. And to our audience, if you want to stop being invisible as a business, if you're an invisible man or a visible person or a visible woman, that's another story. But if your business is feeling that way, you know, and you want to show up where it counts, go find Patrick at pointmannc.com. You can also Connect with him on LinkedIn at Pointman PR. That's P-O-I-N-T.
M-A-N-P-R. And a big thank you to Carl Richards for doing the introduction between Patrick and Knack 4 Business. Carl is from Podcast Solutions Made Simple. key thing here is if you're feeling like your business is vanilla, reach out to Patrick. He will make you the spicier edition. You he'll add flavor and flair.
And to reach us, it's knack4business.com. It's K-N-A-C-K, the number 4 business.com. Use our chatbot. You can find out about other shows or reach out and book a call.